First, let me say this: there is nothing wrong with being a babysitter. I was one in high school. But today, I get quite annoyed when friends ask me “Do you have to babysit tomorrow?”.
I feel like when people ask me that, they are downgrading my work to something that I just kinda fell into, rather then an actual career path I studied really hard in school for. So why did I choose childcare? Why be a nanny? And what exactly IS the difference between a babysitter and a nanny? Is a nanny just a full-time babysitter?
I know it can be difficult to understand the differences between a babysitter and a nanny at first. Perhaps you haven’t been around children that much; or you are a first time parent and just beginning to learn about the different aspects of raising a child. The greatest thing you can do for your infant is provide them with the best childcare you can afford; that includes a nanny, daycare and/or a stay-at-home parent/relative.
Having a solid understanding of the different types of childcare available before you begin your search will help to ease some of the stress, and allow you to find the best care for your child.
My short answer to the babysitter vs. nanny question: A babysitter keeps your kids alive, clean and fed. A nanny keeps your kids alive, clean and fed… as they help to develop social skills, cognitive and physical abilities while incorporating the parents’ philosophies and guidelines.
My previous employer’s answer: “A babysitter is someone who comes to your house maybe for a few hours, plays for a bit but is basically there to make sure the walls are still standing when you get back. A nanny is someone is who takes the time to teach and care for your children, and that you’re 100% comfortable leaving your children with because you know they are in good hands.”
So what’s a nanny?
A nanny is a person who is has made a long-term commitment to the family they work for and is personally invested in the children for whom he/she is responsible, in a regular and ongoing arrangement.
A qualified nanny has gone through some kind of formal training, whether it is a college degree in child development or parenting courses. Nannies have monumental significance in the intellectual and emotional development of their young charges– and the best nannies know how to make the most of this to help the child(ren) achieve their maximum potential.
All day long, I am actively aware of my position and the importance of keeping my full attention on the little one with me– and it’s not just to make sure she’s not running out into the street. Whether it’s:
- Keeping up verbal interaction, which is correlated with higher IQ
- Making recommendations to the family for age-appropriate books, play, meals, outings, exploring
- Finding opportunities to teach during playtime or while on outing
- Keeping up with the latest studies and science on kid’s nutrition, behavior, development
- I must also be aware of the child’s own self, of her sense of independence, emotions, opinions, and ideas. I must provide her with an safe environment where she can freely express herself without fear of failure, judgment or ridicule.
Now, along with keeping in mind all of that, I must also implement the values and ideas from the parents, to make sure that I am keeping the little one on the same path her parents want her to be on. This comes into play on so many levels:
- Dietary concerns. Some of the guidelines from my current family: no fast food, organic whenever possible, but desserts and sweets are ok.
- Discipline. With kids you have to pick your battles and your methods. How to deal effectively with biting, tantrums and other undesirable behaviors should be discussed.
- Educational methods. Just as preschools have different philosophies, so do parents. My current family prefers play-based learning versus structured-academic.
- TV and electronics. Is the family strictly against exposure to TV and computers? Or strictly for it, with TVs and smartphones always on? Or somewhere in the middle?
In summary, a nanny is a person is who not only committed to your child, but to your family as well. Most nannies have many years of experience working with children, and some have an education in child development/psychology that they bring into their positions within families. These are the nannies you want, a person who values and respects her job and her duties and has a full understanding of the influence they wield.
What’s a babysitter?
A babysitter is defined by limits: the duration of their exposure to your kids, the skills required, and the scope of responsibilities. A sitter tends to have a short term, on-call presence in your children’s lives. There is minimal training necessary to be considered a qualified babysitter. A babysitter can be very fond of or even love your children, but he/she does not have any long-term responsibility for mental and emotional growth.
And because sitters typically do not spend significant time with the children, they don’t have the same level of knowledge of the parents’ philosophies. What should be done if Jack isn’t sharing with his sister? How does the family feel about fast food? What are the three most important learning activities for this age? A nanny should know the answer to all those questions. A sitter probably will not.
I hope that was helpful. Please let me know in the comments if you have any questions!